Leave this site
We use some essential cookies to make our website work. We’d like to set additional cookies so we can remember your preferences and understand how you use our site.
You can manage your preferences and cookie settings at any time by clicking on “Customise Cookies” below. For more information on how we use cookies, please see our Cookies notice.
Your cookie preferences have been saved. You can update your cookie settings at any time on the cookies page.
Your cookie preferences have been saved. You can update your cookie settings at any time on the cookies page.
Sorry, there was a technical problem. Please try again.
This site is a beta, which means it's a work in progress and we'll be adding more to it over the next few weeks. Your feedback helps us make things better, so please let us know what you think.
I have read all the papers presented to me and heard the case put forward by the Appropriate Authority.
In particular, the certificate issued by A/Deputy Chief Constable Lucy Morris as Appropriate Authority (AA) that the special conditions for an accelerated misconduct hearing are met under S49 Police Conduct Regulations (PCR) 2020. I fully concur with this decision.
I have considered the written submissions prepared by Detective Inspector Lisa Hurrell as the presenting officer on behalf of the Appropriate Authority. I have also read the documentation pack provided in support of the hearing.
I have also read and reminded myself of Home Office Guidance 2020, the College of Policing (COP) Code of Ethics relevant at the time, the Standards of Professional Behaviour as set out in Schedule 2 of the Police (Conduct) Regulations 2020 and the COP guidance on outcomes in police misconduct proceedings as updated in August 2022.
In this and all my determinations on decisions, I am considering the information and evidence I am provided with and assessing this against the test of ‘balance of probability’.
No application for reporting restrictions was made, and I do not impose any reporting restrictions in relation to this matter.
The hearing was held in public in accordance with the principle of transparency that applies to accelerated misconduct hearings.
Former Police Constable 81526 Nicholas Davies resigned from Essex Police on the 1st June 2026. The Regulation 51 notice was served through his Federation representative, Mark Thrower, by email on the 23rd October 2026. On 26th October 2026, Mr Thrower confirmed that Former Police Constable Davies did not wish to provide a formal response and would not attend or participate in the hearing process. The notice of the accelerated misconduct hearing, confirming that the hearing would take place on the 12th November 2026, was also received by Mr Thrower on 23rd October 2026. Former Police Constable Davies was therefore appropriately notified of the proceedings and communicated a clear decision, through his Federation representative, not to attend or participate. No application was made for an adjournment or for any alternative arrangement to facilitate his participation.
The Appropriate Authority submitted that there was no procedural impediment arising from Former Police Constable Davies’ non-attendance and invited me to proceed in his absence under Regulation 57(3)(b) of the Police (Conduct) Regulations 2020. I have considered the circumstances carefully. Former Police Constable Davies was properly notified, had access to advice through his Federation representative and made a clear and informed decision not to engage. No request was made to delay the proceedings. I am satisfied that proceeding in his absence is fair, proportionate and in the public interest.
I therefore determined that the hearing should proceed and be concluded in the absence of Former Police Constable 81526 Nicholas Davies.
The Appropriate Authority have set out clearly in the opening note and in the allegation of the breaches of the Standards of Professional Behaviour against Former Police Constable 81526 Nicholas Davies and the officer’s conduct.
The AA sets out the behaviour of Former Police Constable 81526 Nicholas Davies as the following:
The Regulation 51 notice identifies the Standards of Professional Behaviour alleged to have been breached as Orders and Instructions, Duties and Responsibilities, and Discreditable Conduct.
I have considered the allegations as set out in the Regulation 51 notice against the standard of a balance of probability. I have been clear to consider the comprehensive evidence set out by the AA in the bundle and the specific points that Former Police Constable 81526 Nicholas Davies and that, notwithstanding his absence, the burden remains with the Appropriate Authority to prove the case on the balance of probabilities. I have had throughout in my mind the point made clearly by the AA that it is their job to prove the case.
Former Police Constable Davies does not dispute the underlying facts. They are supported by the body worn video footage, his interview account, the STORM records and the calls made to Essex Police by public witnesses. Former PC Davies’ reaction on seeing the cyclist demonstrates that he recognised the danger, yet he took no positive action to mitigate the risk. I therefore find the facts proven on the balance of probabilities.
The AA proposed that the following standards are engaged as set out in the conduct above:
I agree with the Appropriate Authority that all three Standards of Professional Behaviour are engaged.
Former Police Constable Davies failed to comply with the fundamental requirement placed upon police officers to protect life and respond appropriately to an identifiable risk. By taking no action and failing to notify the Force Control Room or another officer, he failed to carry out his duties diligently and responsibly.
His subsequent access to STORM and review of his body worn video, without escalating what he had witnessed, compounded that failure. Conduct of this nature is also capable of seriously undermining public confidence in policing and therefore amounts to Discreditable Conduct.
In considering whether the behaviour is misconduct or gross misconduct, I have consulted and considered Home Office guidance for Conduct Efficiency and Effectiveness 2020 as well as the College of Policing (COP) Guidance on Outcomes in Police Conduct Proceedings 2023.
Regulation 2 of the Police Conduct Regulations defines gross misconduct as a breach of the Standards of Professional Behaviour that is so serious as to justify dismissal.
After carefully considering all of the information presented to me, I find that former Police Constable Davies’ actions represent a serious breach of the Standards of Professional Behaviour.
This matter involved a failure to respond to an identifiable risk to life, despite Former Police Constable Davies having recognised the danger. He did not stop, turn around when safe to do so, or alert the force control room or a local unit. Former PC Davies later heard radio transmissions concerning the collision, accessed the relevant STORM incidents and reviewed his body worn video, but did not escalate what he had witnessed. I have taken account of the fact that Former Police Constable Davies’ actions were not intentional or deliberate, together with his explanation that he believed the cyclist would leave the carriageway of his own accord.
However, these matters must be considered alongside the seriousness of the risk, his policing duty to protect life, and his subsequent failure to escalate the risk he had observed.
I have made no decision as to outcome at this stage.
Considering the conduct and the definition of gross misconduct in the Home Office Guidance, I find that this conduct amounts to gross misconduct.
I have reviewed the College of Policing guidance when assessing this matter. I have first assessed the seriousness of the misconduct, taking into account the culpability, harm, aggravating and mitigating factors.
The primary duty of a police officer is to protect life, as reflected in the oath taken upon joining. While Former Police Constable Davies’ actions were not intentional or deliberate, he could reasonably have foreseen the risk of harm arising from his failure to take action.
His own reaction, captured on body worn video, demonstrated that he recognised the danger presented by a cyclist travelling towards oncoming traffic on a fast moving road. Although it cannot now be established whether intervention would have changed the tragic outcome, he should have acted upon what he observed in an attempt to mitigate the risk.
The risks associated with Former Police Constable Davies’ behaviour were significant. The cyclist was travelling against the flow of traffic in darkness, without lights or high visibility clothing, on a road with no hard shoulder or accessible footpath. Tragically, the cyclist later died following a road traffic collision, causing profound harm to their family and friends. I do not attribute the death to Former Police Constable Davies’ inaction; however, his failure to take any reasonable step in response to an identifiable risk to life is capable of causing significant harm to public confidence in policing. The public rightly expect police officers to act proactively to keep people safe.
Following the incident, Former Police Constable Davies heard radio transmissions relating to the collision and later accessed both STORM incidents and reviewed his body worn video, but he did not escalate the matter, seek advice or tell a colleague or supervisor what he had witnessed. The incident occurred on a fast moving road, and the risk was immediate and obvious. Despite this, he did not stop, turn around, notify the control room or take any other reasonable action to mitigate the identified risk to life.
There are limited mitigating factors. This appears to relate to a single episode of conduct rather than a wider pattern of behaviour. Former Police Constable Davies admitted his inaction in interview, expressed genuine remorse and said that, with hindsight, he wished he had done more. Former PC Davies resignation may represent an acknowledgement of the seriousness of his actions. These matters provide context but do not excuse his fundamental failure to respond to the risk before him.
I have considered the three character references provided and Former Police Constable Davies’ record of service. They describe him as a hard working, committed and valued member of his team. I have also considered his remorse and the personal consequences of his resignation. However, personal mitigation carries limited weight where the conduct has caused serious harm to public confidence. The public are entitled to expect police officers to act when faced with an identifiable risk to life, and the distress caused to the family and loved ones of the individual who died must remain central to my assessment.
The college of policing guidance clearly sets out the purpose of police misconduct proceedings. These are threefold.
It is essential that through any outcome I prevent harm to the public, officers, and staff and to the trust and confidence in policing. I must protect the public from any further risk that might be caused if former Former Police Constable Davies is allowed to continue to be part of the police service.
The proven allegations against Former Police Constable Davies need to be dealt with seriously to demonstrate to the public and other officers that this conduct is intolerable and will not be allowed.
The public are entitled to know that they can trust officers to abide by the standards of professional behaviour required and that where officers do not, they will be held to account. The public must be able to trust officers and Former Police Constable Davies’ actions undermine this.
In considering the purpose of Police Conduct procedures and the information I have read and heard in this case I have looked at the outcomes available to me. As the notice of the accelerated misconduct hearing was served after May 2025, the presumption of dismissal applies. I have nevertheless considered the full range of available outcomes and must ensure that the outcome imposed is appropriate and proportionate to the seriousness of the conduct.
This is a matter where there is a presumption of dismissal unless exceptional circumstances justify a lesser outcome. I remain conscious that I must impose the outcome most appropriate to the seriousness of the conduct.
Given the seriousness of the conduct, taking no action would not be appropriate and would not meet the purpose of police conduct procedures, notwithstanding that Former Police Constable Davies has resigned. I have identified no exceptional circumstances, and none were put forward by the Appropriate Authority or on his behalf.
The only outcome available to me that meets the purpose of police conduct procedures is dismissal without notice had Former Police Constable Davies still been serving. This outcome protects the public both now and in the future, maintains public trust and confidence in policing, and reinforces the standards expected of all police officers.
I have considered the available mitigation, including Former Police Constable Davies’ remorse, his belief at the time that the cyclist would move to safety, his resignation, his record of service, and the three character references. However, these matters do not outweigh the seriousness of his failure to act when faced with an obvious risk to life. A lesser outcome would not adequately maintain public confidence, uphold high professional standards or protect the public. Dismissal without notice would therefore have been necessary and proportionate.
Having considered all of the circumstances and facts, I find that the only appropriate outcome is dismissal without notice had Former Police Constable Davies still been serving.
No reporting restrictions were imposed at the hearing and that remains the position.
Former Police Constable 81526 Nicholas Davies’ name and the findings of the hearing should be made public internally and externally in the interests of public trust and confidence and to reenforce the standards expected by the public, policing and Essex Police.
Former Police Constable 81526 Nicholas Davies will be added to the College of Policing barred list.
Rachel Nolan
Chief Constable of Essex Police
12th November 2026